In a word, maybe. Many of you have heard this from friends when you tell them about CrossFit. Some will talk about articles they’ve read about rhabdo and other such injuries. The truth is that CrossFit’s methodology is incredibly effective in achieving GPP when executed correctly. But, in all athletic activities where the challenge is intense physically and mentally, there is an element of danger.

CrossFit WODs are often referred to as intense. CrossFit defines intensity as going as fast and hard as you physically AND mentally can. Although for some, describing Fran as intense may be a ridiculous understatement, but the definition still applies. There are innumerable factors that factor into a WOD such as:

  • the athlete’s current and past fitness level, tenacity, and ego
  • the trainers’ experience, knowledge, and ego
  • the athlete’s sleep, diet, and recovery
  • the wod’s movements, loading, reps, and intensity
  • the previous day’s wod’s movements, loading, etc
  • the environment’s temperature, humidity, and altitude

Most of the serious injuries that have come out of CrossFit occur with athletes who have an incredible tolerance for pain and have pushed the mental envelope to its limits in the past. Their bodies are in decent shape, but their minds remember how to push as if they are the finely tuned athletes they were a few years back. The mind, then is both a beautiful and dangerous thing. It’s then the coach’s job to scale back this athlete’s reps, weights, and sets until his body catches up with his mind.

Other times injuries occur from weaknesses and inflexibilities that have accumulated over the years that prevent us from performing the functional movements our bodies were meant to. Here, it’s up to the coach to identify the mobility issues, scale back (or sub) necessary movements until the athlete is capable of performing these lifts safely.

I’ve also seen people suffer through a WOD and look like roadkill afterwards (ok, MORE like roadkill than usual) only to tell me they slept two hours or haven’t eaten all day. Here, it’s the athlete’s job to keep the coach informed about their condition. There is merit to training for the unknown and the unknowable, but there is also stupidity in trying to throw heavy weight around when you are not physically OR mentally capable of it. So, embrace the suck but do so intelligently. There is a time and a place for bootcamp style training, but not while snatching your bodyweight.

Hopefully this helps you when your friends try to quote numerous articles about the dangers of CrossFit. Long story short (too late), CrossFit is only dangerous if the coach or athlete acts irresponsibly or without regard for the athlete’s long term health and wellness. We as CrossFitters poke fun at ‘globo gyms’ but our culture has sprouted a new breed of “CrossFit globos” where shredded hands are a badge of honor, where Rx’d is a religion, and where form and safety are traded for seconds shaved off their girl WODs.

It is an athlete’s responsibility to find a coach (in CrossFit or any sport) who knows the importance of scaling, recognizes athletes’ limitations and strengths (especially if those strengths become limitations), cares about the athletes’ longevity beyond the immediate future, and maintains an open line of communication with their athletes. Trying to wrench your body through movements or under loads that you’re not prepared for is dangerous and so is a coach that permits and/or encourages it.


WOD 01.17.12

Barbara5rds:

  • 20 Pull Ups
  • 30 Push Ups
  • 40 Sit Ups
  • 50 Squats

35 Minute Cap

9 Responses to “From the CFI Vault: Is CrossFit Dangerous?”

troy
January 17, 2012 at 8:27 AM

I’m stoked on seeing todays Wod. Long, painful and a time challenge. Bring it.

Tom
January 17, 2012 at 9:11 AM

Troy, quit showing off….. On the real, how are you and the rest of the gang doing???

For this WOD are we doing the 3 minute rest between rounds??????

ruth
January 17, 2012 at 9:18 AM

No rest, straight through!

the Pooj
January 17, 2012 at 9:31 AM

i dont know what you trainers did to brain wash us… but i woke up and got a little excited about the wod today. what’s wrong with me?! glad there’s a cap :)

troy
January 17, 2012 at 11:34 AM

Pooj your stoked cause its going to be long and hard… no dirty joke implied.

Tom doing well, i don’t want to speak for others but i would hope everyone else is doing the same. How are things over there? The adult content i promised you may not make it, but ill work on getting something good sent over.

becky
January 17, 2012 at 12:29 PM

timeless post, Ruth!!
thanks!

A.J.
January 17, 2012 at 1:30 PM

This workout sounds dangerous, glad I WOD shopped before signing up…

Dan
January 17, 2012 at 2:55 PM

This one broke my central nervous system, but a fun one. Pace and have fun everyone.

the Pooj
January 17, 2012 at 4:30 PM

WOD SHOPPING!?!!! isn’t that a burpee penalty?! it better be because i will never forget the 50+ burpees i owed… i want justice.

see you tonight :)